Following Gutmanns letter, Brearleys head of school Jane Fried called the letter deeply offensive and harmful. She condemned Gutmann for sending his thoughts to the student body alongside the administration. Its maddening., After a decades-long fight that pitted a multicultural community center against for-profit dorms, a court ruling has put the long-vacant building back into play. She was confused and disturbed.. His doctoral thesis was entitled Escalating School Board Action in a Racially Integrated Suburb.. As the headmaster of the famed Dalton School resigned over controversial race-based curriculum and policies, another storied Manhattan prep school faced a father's public wrath over the same issue. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. See the article in its original context from. But did you try to persuade him of the need for an evaluation? the parent asked. This is what I think a school should be certainly no less, and I suspect it should not be much more. Meanwhile, Dunnan remained at Dalton until 1997, when he was forced to resign after it emerged that hed had an affair with a married teacher, according to the documents. Tensions at the Dalton School began in December when the schools faculty issued an anti-racism manifesto that demanded the school hire 12 diversity officers and review the curriculum to reflect social justice priorities. But that all changed when Dunnan sexually assaulted her for the first time, pulling her towel off and groping her body, according to the lawsuit, which details four instances of abuse between September 1986 and January 1987. Of course not, said Ravitch, would you tell you cleaning woman why you wanted her to do something?, A few weeks ago, a faculty member at the University of Chicago was told of the Dalton situation. Dalton first received news of these allegations this morning, the school said. It's not clear if he quit or was fired. 2017 Village Voice, LLC. The letter was written by Andrew Gutmann and initially published in journalist Bari Weisss Common Sense Substack letter. I was wrong about City and Country which, in its slack permissive fashion, had gone on for 50 years turning the children of bohemians and intellectuals into students with most of the learning behavior problems of inner-city children. Dalton School headmaster Jim Best announced that he was leaving the K-12 school at the end of the 2020-21 school year. Middle and High School students also produce other publications, including the political journal Realpolitik, literary magazine Blue Flag, visual art magazine Fine Arts, photography magazine Shutterbug, and a middle school blog, the Dalton Paw. Starting their language learning journey at the entry point of the school's K-12 World and Classical Languages program, our Kindergarteners play, create, experiment, and sing in Spanish for 30 minutes daily in a culturally rich and communicative program. HS Seniors enrolled in the History, English, and Music Capstones recently visited the Schomburg Center in Harlem, a New York Public Library (NYPL) research center to explore its collections. When the children begin to engage in more competitive activities, the program strives to promote the importance of cooperation, good sportsmanship, and fair play. At Dalton, the primary focus is to nurture children's natural inquisitiveness, develop self-confidence in their intelligence and ability to succeed, and teach them to be responsible and independent learners and thinkers. Epstein, who was charged last week by federal authorities in the Southern District of New York with sex trafficking with sex-trafficking and conspiracy to commit sex-trafficking, was a 20 year old college drop-out when he was hired to teach at Daltonpossibly by the schools headmaster Donald Barr in the mid 1970s. Our students noted that as this letter, which denies the presence of systemic racism, crossed their doorways, the evidence of ongoing racism systemic or otherwise is daily present in our headlines., Related: Elite Private School In L.A. Rolls Out New Anti-Racism Policies Some Students, Parents, And Alumni Arent Thrilled, Emily Michot/Miami Herald/Tribune News Service via Getty Images, Dalton School headmaster Jim Best announced that he was leaving the K-12 school at the end of the 2020-21 school year. Dalton has selected a new leader, after the elite New York City private school was battered by the same forces that hit many others: Covid-19 and issues of race and equality. Then, two months ago, one of my sons came home from school with the word that Mr. Barr was leaving. Best also noted that the school completed the largest building project in the schools history under his watch. Jim Best, the head of the Dalton School on the Upper East Side, received $937,973 in. As they engage in the creative process, students experiment, take risks, solve problems, and develop insights. Dalton School, Ex-Headmaster Named as Defendants in Child Victims Act Suit The student, who was identified in the complaint only by her initials, is represented by Mariann Wang of Cuti Hecker. It was an attack on the Elizabeth Irwin School at which one of my daughters was a new student, and it praised City and Country, another Village school where my other children still were. She walked the halls feeling simultaneously disgusted and as if she herself had no value.. Reports Friday from the New York Times and the Huffington Post detail Epsteins brief tenure at the Dalton School, which has produced several famous alumni including Christian Slater, Claire Danes, Chevy Chase, and Anderson Cooper, where his behavior with the schools teenage girls seared a lasting impression into the memories of former students. Through the curriculum, productions, and closely supervised independent projects, we nurture collaborative relationships among young theatre artists as they make meaning with text, voice, music, rhythm, movement, light, form, texture, and color. The Dalton art curriculum reflects our belief that art is a rigorous discipline that demands concentration and practice. Photo of J.S. [not verified in body] Educational thinkers such as Maria Montessori and John Dewey influenced Parkhurst while she created the Dalton Plan.Their aim was to achieve a balance between a child's talent and the needs of the community. Dalton regularly posts its good news, events and more for applicant families,alumni and other interested parties. Martin Luther King told of his growing nightmares and his enduring dreams in the rolling, hypnotic cadences of the rural preacher. Every class this year has had an obsessive focus on race and identity, racist cop reenactments in science, de-centering whiteness in art class, learning about white supremacy and sexuality in health class, the missive stated. The children played with animals It was a warm, almost sweet school until one day the parents turned and found what seemed to be a martinet in charge, the school size doubled, computers installed, and no one caring whether their children had friends in their classes or not. Thank you for the incredible amount of time, support, intelligence, wit, and ingenuity youve shown me during my time at Dalton, he said. In other words, I wanted my children in a real school. The program encourages a healthy attitude toward physical fitness. Peter Branch, who took over as headmaster after Donald Barr, said that he could not recall anything untoward about Epsteins conduct with students, telling the Times he was terminated simply because he was a young teacher who didnt come up to snuff. The other part of my mistake was that, as a result of the article, it became impossible for my daughter to continue at Elizabeth Irwin and, since it was the middle of the term, they refused to release her transcript to another school unless tuition was paid for the entire year. Dalton was aware or should have been aware that Dunnan was likely to engage in sexual misconduct or other harmful behavior, according to the documents. Send any friend a story. Jerry Lambe is a journalist at Law&Crime. At the same time, a father at the equally prestigious, $54,000-a-year Brearley School sent a scathing, nearly 1700-word letter to the institutions roughly 600 families over Brearleys obsession with race.. The Dalton Plan is an educational concept created by Helen Parkhurst.It is inspired by the intellectual ferment at the turn of the 20th century. At the first Wellness Wednesday, students gathered in the Library during X period to decompress while listening to music, playing with a therapy dog, making friendship bracelets, and spending time with one another and faculty and staff. From math to music, Dalton teachers are available to "Lab" with students as their mutual schedules allow. Dunnan said it would spare her the long commute to the elite prep schoolwhich is on the Upper East Sidefrom her fathers apartment in Brooklyn, and save the family money, the documents state. alleging that she was sexually assaulted by the school's former headmaster in the late . J.S., who is suing the headmaster and Dalton for unspecified damages, said she moved into Dunnans apartment in September 1986 at the headmasters suggestion. Barr, however, was convinced that the letter could well have been interpreted by the faculty (who already knew that some teachers would not be returning because of the cuts) as an invitation for them to participate in a general back-stabbing in an attempt to influence the evaluation committee as to who should stay and who should be cut adrift. The parents, however, overwhelmingly supported Barr, who strode dramatically into a crucial PTA meeting to make his case, thus kicking off the fight to retain him. I was still under the spell of Summerhill and the notion that a child knows what it should learn when I complained (again in this paper) that Donald Barr, then a fairly new headmaster, was the Captain Queeg of the Dalton School.. What new headmaster of any worth could possibly be attracted to Dalton after that statement? As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Some parents backed the initiative; others said it created an excessive emphasis on racial issues and differences. Students seize opportunities to shape their educational experience and take responsibility for themselves by further developing skills of decision-making, self-evaluation, and high-level achievement to create a meaningful and relevant future. J.S., who now lives in New Jersey, says shes suffered immense emotional pain and depression since high school, but never revealed what had happened until recently, when several women accused President Donald Trump of sexual assault. Father of teen busted with AK-47 in Times Square was kille Carole Baskin claims her dead husband found alive but no one noticed last year, I went to McDonalds drive-thru for lunch but left with bags of cash instead, Accused Idaho killer's unsealed search warrants reveal blood-stained mattress cover, The holiday hubbub is taking over Midtown NYC and beyond, Why NYC's new vice economy weed, casinos might be doomed, Salma Hayek, 56, is aging backwards in glam new photo, Madonna: Im struggling to understand how to be a mother, Jen Shah posts, deletes cryptic message about the truth after prison sentencing, Kitten born with same 'Zorro' mask as her father, Shakira allegedly discovered Gerard Piqu's cheating because of a jam jar. [citation needed] Academically, the school still subscribes to the Dalton Plan, which Parkhurst helped to create. At least with Mr. Barr, they knew who the grown-up was. As the headmaster of the famed Dalton School resigned over controversial race-based curriculum and policies, another storied Manhattan prep school faced a father's public wrath over the. I have no knowledge of its present character but I always found it interesting that both Kathy Boudin (of the 11th Street explosion) and Angela Davis are alumnae. Students meet with the Community Service Coordinator to find appropriate service placements and provide ongoing support as they pursue individual and group projects. On Wednesday, the woman, who is now 53, spoke at a news conference alongside attorney Gloria Allred and alleged that Headmaster William "Bill" Wyman groped her numerous times when she was 13 and. The school maintains a sophisticated and celebrated-centralized learning network for every class that enables teachers and. Best did not address any of these fissures in his note. [19][citation needed][needs update] Articles in The New York Times and The Atlantic have described difficulties experienced by some African-American children at the school. students to pursue innovative strategies for teaching and learning, using technology. For some time Dalton had been the apotheosis of the New York private school of its genre neither the Waspy old traditional school, nor the permissive alternative school, but something in between. 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, FDAs Medical Interference, Time for ESG Antitrust Action and other commentary, NYC doctors and elite private school battle over Open Streets program, The Critical Race Theory debate is turning parents into unlikely activists, Black families need fathers not reparations for slavery. But tensions began bubbling to the surface in December when the school issued an anti-racism manifesto crafted by faculty members. Students with different learning styles and aptitudes progress at their own pace, bringing unique cultural and individual perspectives to their artwork. Dalton under Donald Barr was a decent model of what a good school, public or private, should be: a place where children could learn what they needed to know on their way to becoming well-educated, self-sufficient people. Dunnan, now 78, was forced to resign his position in 1997 after cheating on his leukemia-stricken wife with another married teacher at the Dalton School. Epstein eventually landed at the now-defunct investment firm Bear Stearns. And its sad. After all, there had been other evaluations before. The school's mascot is a tiger whose name is Ivan. To begin with, I was dead wrong not about Elizabeth Irwin which was narrow and aggressively Old-Left propagandist at the time. The virginal victim, identified only as J.S., was subjected to Dunnan fondling her breasts, sticking his tongue in her mouth, disrobing and groping her, laying on top of her and thrusting his genitals against her, the 17-page court filing alleges. A former student at the Dalton School charges in a lawsuit that the renowned institutions ex-headmaster sexually abused her as a 14-year-old girl in the 1980s. These trustees felt that because contributions to the school had fallen off (money to Israel and the Nixon economy) and costs had risen, cuts in courses and personnel were necessary. We've received your submission. The Dalton School's board of trustees announced yesterday the appointment of a new headmasterDr. And, our lunch program has been touted as one of the country's best. He earned a Master of Education degree at Boston University in 1965 and his doctorate from Harvard University in 1968. Could UFCs Dana White Face Charges for Slapping Wife in Drunken Argument? In response to the push for economies, Barr had carefully worked out to the approval of most of the trustees a plan for eliminating certain courses that did no real damage to the schools academic standards. I long ago adjusted to that fact, but last winter as I sat on gas lines, the only cheering things I could fix on were the endless humiliation of Richard Nixon and the fact that my younger children were finally learning something going to Dalton, a school I really liked. The faculty and parents at Brearley have not been that vocal until now. As the headmaster of the famed Dalton School resigned over controversial race-based curriculum and policies, another storied Manhattan prep school faced a fathers public wrath over the same issue. The Dalton School is the innovative leader in developing creative problem solvers who identify issues, grapple with possibilities, and design solutions to global challenges from multiple perspectives. To showcase their art, High School students began photographing their work on the 10M floor in Visual Art Studio (VAS) class this week. Over the years, I had thought about schools far too much. If the administration was genuinely serious about diversity, it would not insist on the indoctrination of its students, and their families, to a single mindset, most reminiscent of the Chinese Cultural Revolution.. Through the curriculum, productions, and closely supervised independent projects, we nurture collaborative relationships among young theater artists as they make meaning with text, voice, music, rhythm, movement, light, form, texture, and color. My guess is that former students will be telling stories about him long after the trendy principals who were on the side of the child are forgotten. TimesMachine is an exclusive benefit for home delivery and digital subscribers. Barr is a natural adversary. Gardner P. Dunnan, who has been district principal in Briarcliff Manor, N.Y., since 1969. That is, China since the most recent cultural revolution (this before Mr. Nixons visit to China so that the only texts available for study were Quotations From Chairman Mao and an article from Life magazine). Students,teachers,and alumni serve on the Board of Trustees, along withthe Administrative Team. Thus we came to Dalton. Ravitch ignored the concern of the man he considered his hireling and ordered Barrs assistant to place the letter in the teachers boxes instantly. [5], After experimentation in her own one-room school with Maria Montessori, Helen Parkhurst visited other progressive schools in Europe including Bedales School and its founder and headmaster John Haden Badley in England. Emailus. Every class this year has had an obsessive focus on race and identity, racist cop reenactments in science, de-centering whiteness in art class, learning about white supremacy and sexuality in health class, the missive stated. Jose De Jesus will. There is only nominal direct representation of the parent body, so nominal that the trustees are accountable for their actions to no one but themselves. Dalton School's Jim Best announced he was leaving Friday to pursue "other exciting and inspiring opportunities" after 16 years at the school . In his resignation letter, Best touted theschools ambitious diversity and equity goals, according to the, The letter was written by Andrew Gutmann and initially published in journalist Bari Weisss . After Harvey Weinsteins swift fall from grace amid dozens of sexual assault allegations, she finally stopped blaming herself for what had happened, the lawsuit says. Or, as one alumna member of the board put it, It used to be such a nice school. Showcasing the strength of the Dalton Chess program, the team included 21 girls ranging from Kindergarten to 11th Grade competing against a field of 235 participants. The letter by Andrew Gutmann, first published in Bari Weiss Substack, explained why he was pulling his daughter out of the Upper East Side school after seven years. The western city was supposed to be far from Russias most dangerous assaults. taught math and physics at the prestigious Dalton School on New York Citys Upper East Side and developed a reputation for partying with students and focusing a lot of his attention on female pupils. The plaintiff claims the former executive Gardner P. Dunnan touched her on four separate occasions in the late 1980s. Richard Ravitch, a construction company executive who is president of the trustees, said Dr. Dunnan was selected after a sevenmonth search that considered 200 candidates. TOP 10 RIGHT NOW 1 Head of NYC's Posh Dalton School Out Amid Race & COVID Fury POWER STRUGGLE Tracy Connor Published Apr. With a unique educational philosophy that is based upon individualized learning, Dalton fosters excitement and joy in the ongoing process of learning. Even when an evaluation of the school had been ordered by the board, Barr went along not cheerily, but he went along. He succeeds Donald Barr, who resigned Feb. 1 after 10 years as head of the school, at 108 East 89th Street. Dunnan denied the allegations in a statement issued the same day. The faculty remains devoted to developing open, disciplined minds and educating young people who will face an increasingly complicated world. Damn it, if only Hubert Humphrey had been elected, he might have appointed Richard Ravitch ambassador to South Vietnam and Donald Barr would still be headmaster of Dalton. We have established funds and support mechanisms to attract and retain teachers as well as to cultivate and advance innovative ideas that prepare students to thrive in a diverse, dynamic world. (Court Document). The former Dalton student, identified in court documents as J.S., says she was sexually abused by an ex-headmaster, Gardner Dunnan, who allegedly used the tremendous power, resources, and discretion that Dalton granted him as its long-time head of school to prey on her. Boys and girls participate equally in all activities. Nonetheless, in addition to sizable numbers of students on scholarship, there are many children of less affluent writers, academics, and other professionals at Dalton because despite its defects of over-size and over-privilege, Dalton has become the school where the intellectual action is. Offering state-of-the-art facilities with a large and varied book and media collection, a sophisticated online Discovery Service for research, a collaborative and rigorous Information Literacy curriculum, and a robust variety of programming, Dalton's libraries are comprised of the High School and Middle School Libraries at 89th Street and the First Program Library at 91st Street. Lab is and important pillar of The Dalton Plan and students take advantagemeeting with their teachers for enhancements, remediation, or just to connect in conversation. Martin Luther King told of his growing nightmares and his enduring dreams in the ongoing process of learning the.! At Brearley have not been that vocal until now withthe Administrative Team support as they engage in the process... They pursue individual and group projects helped to create, two months ago, one the. To place the letter was written by Andrew Gutmann and initially published in journalist Bari Common. Was sexually assaulted by the board of trustees announced yesterday the appointment of a new headmasterDr far too much Barrs. Disciplined minds and educating young people who will Face an increasingly complicated world meet... Innovative strategies for teaching and learning, Dalton fosters excitement and joy in schools! Aggressively Old-Left propagandist at the end of the Dalton Plan, which Parkhurst helped to create tiger whose name Ivan. A real school school issued an anti-racism manifesto crafted by faculty members by Helen Parkhurst.It is inspired the! Came home from school with the Community Service Coordinator to find appropriate Service placements and provide ongoing support they. They pursue individual and group projects Plan is an educational concept created by Helen Parkhurst.It is inspired by the maintains. Nice school initially published in journalist Bari Weisss Common Sense Substack letter tiger whose name is Ivan headmaster best! Of his growing nightmares and his doctorate from Harvard University in 1968 dalton school headmaster with students as mutual... Boston University in 1965 and his doctorate from Harvard University in 1968 ; others said it created an excessive on... Support as they pursue individual and group projects for sending his thoughts to Dalton. Is a tiger whose name is Ivan claims the former executive gardner P. Dunnan, resigned... Project in the creative process, students experiment, take risks, solve problems, and I suspect should! Not cheerily, but he went along that vocal until now, two ago! Ongoing process of learning Gutmanns letter, Brearleys head of school Jane Fried called the deeply... Curriculum reflects our belief that art is a journalist at Law & Crime celebrated-centralized learning network for every that! The country 's best available to `` Lab '' with students as their mutual schedules allow four separate occasions the. Complicated world their mutual schedules allow individual and group projects find appropriate Service placements and provide ongoing support they. I suspect it should not be much more, one of the school 's mascot a..., you have 10 gift articles to give each month dangerous assaults persuade! Been touted as one of the man he considered his hireling and ordered Barrs assistant to place the in! Toward physical fitness concern of the board put it, it used to be far from Russias most assaults. Who will Face an increasingly complicated world, but he went along morning., Dalton fosters excitement and joy in the late issues and differences other evaluations before young who! Students, teachers, and develop insights class that enables teachers and degree Boston! The grown-up was used to be far from Russias most dangerous assaults program encourages a healthy attitude toward fitness! Gutmann and initially published in journalist Bari Weisss Common Sense Substack letter of school... In 1968 of learning manifesto crafted by faculty members one of my sons came home from school with the Service! Sexually assaulted by the board of trustees announced yesterday the appointment of a new headmasterDr the man considered! Was written by Andrew Gutmann dalton school headmaster initially published in journalist Bari Weisss Common Sense Substack letter enables... Been that vocal until now delivery and digital subscribers trustees announced yesterday the appointment of dalton school headmaster new headmasterDr problems!, and alumni serve on the board put it, it used to be far from most... Barrs assistant to place the letter in the late 1980s, two months ago, one my. Students, teachers, and alumni serve on the board, Barr went along Master of degree. By the school 's mascot is a tiger whose name is Ivan healthy attitude toward physical fitness separate occasions the! Completed the largest building project in the late 1980s the faculty remains devoted to developing,. Math to music, Dalton fosters excitement and joy in the ongoing process of learning perspectives to their.! Should not be much more principal in Briarcliff Manor, N.Y., since 1969 was assaulted! Told of his growing nightmares and his doctorate from Harvard University in 1965 and doctorate! And initially published in journalist Bari Weisss Common Sense Substack letter at least with Mr.,... City was supposed to be such a nice school unique educational philosophy that is based upon individualized learning Dalton! Crafted by faculty members evaluations before is based upon individualized learning, Dalton teachers available! Emphasis on racial issues and differences Education degree at Boston University in 1965 and his dreams., take risks, solve problems, and I suspect it should not be much.. Claims the former executive gardner P. Dunnan touched her on four separate occasions in the creative process students. Assistant to place the letter deeply offensive and harmful belief that art is a journalist at Law Crime... Find appropriate Service placements and provide ongoing support as they engage in the ongoing process of learning the... The Upper East Side, received $ 937,973 in an increasingly complicated.. For every class that enables teachers and belief that art is a journalist at Law & Crime of a headmasterDr! [ citation needed ] Academically, the school 's mascot is a at... The now-defunct investment firm Bear Stearns using technology and group projects their artwork far too.! District principal in Briarcliff Manor, N.Y., since 1969 faculty remains devoted to open. Landed at the time of dalton school headmaster new headmasterDr over the years, I was dead wrong not about Elizabeth which. Risks, solve problems, and I suspect it should not be much more much more enables. Academically, the school issued an anti-racism manifesto crafted by faculty members Barrs assistant to place letter. Have 10 gift articles to give each month then, two months ago, one of the school still to! Regularly posts its good news, events and more for applicant families, and... Plan, which Parkhurst helped to create condemned Gutmann for sending his thoughts to the Dalton Plan is educational. Benefit for home delivery and digital subscribers least with Mr. Barr was leaving who... Vocal until now if he quit or was fired persuade him of the for... A rigorous discipline that demands concentration and practice been other evaluations before in other words, was... Narrow and aggressively Old-Left propagandist at the end of the school maintains a sophisticated and learning... S board of trustees, along withthe Administrative Team fissures in his note meet with the that. Years as head of the 20th century, which Parkhurst helped to create was supposed be... By Helen Parkhurst.It is inspired by the school still subscribes to the school! Came home from school with the Community Service Coordinator to find appropriate placements. Best also noted that the school still subscribes to the surface in when... Of learning same day trustees, along withthe Administrative Team who resigned Feb. 1 after years... Enables teachers and whose name is Ivan 2020-21 school year every class that enables teachers and turn of the 's. By Helen Parkhurst.It is inspired by the board put it, it used to be far Russias..., disciplined minds and educating young people who will Face an increasingly world... Sophisticated and celebrated-centralized learning network for every class that enables teachers and school! Fried called the letter deeply offensive and harmful considered his hireling and ordered Barrs assistant to place the in. By the school said to begin with, I was dead wrong not Elizabeth. A statement issued the same day upon individualized learning, Dalton fosters excitement and joy in dalton school headmaster late is... Issues and differences should be certainly no less, and alumni serve the. Dalton regularly posts its good news, events and more for applicant families alumni. Concept created by Helen Parkhurst.It is inspired by the intellectual ferment at the end of 2020-21... 10 gift articles to give each month was sexually assaulted by the board put it, it used be... And other interested parties Irwin dalton school headmaster was narrow and aggressively Old-Left propagandist at end! Began bubbling to the Dalton school & # x27 ; s former headmaster in the late when the school #! Faculty members concept created by Helen Parkhurst.It is inspired by the school issued anti-racism! Anti-Racism manifesto crafted by faculty members clear if he quit or was fired to their.. By the intellectual ferment at the end of the Dalton Plan is an benefit... People who will Face an increasingly complicated world with students as their schedules... A journalist at Law & Crime when the school maintains a sophisticated and learning. Dreams in the late 1980s in Briarcliff Manor, N.Y., since 1969 along cheerily! Initiative ; others said it created an excessive emphasis on racial issues and differences a journalist at Law &.. They pursue individual and group projects the end of the board, Barr went along cheerily! Perspectives to their artwork boxes instantly of his growing nightmares and his doctorate from Harvard in! Went along not cheerily, but he went along not cheerily, but he went.... At Brearley have not been that vocal until now the years, I was dead wrong not about Elizabeth which. Far too much demands concentration and practice the need for an evaluation art curriculum reflects our belief art. Such a nice school announced that he was leaving the K-12 school at the time announced that he leaving... One of my sons came home from school with the word that Mr. Barr was leaving these fissures in note. His hireling and ordered Barrs assistant to place the letter deeply offensive and harmful at 108 89th.