App., June 30, 2020). On the one hand, a court must not hesitate to disqualify an attorney when it is satisfactorily established that he or she wrongfully acquired an unfair advantage that undermines the integrity of the judicial process and will have a continuing effect on the proceedings before the court. On the other hand, it must be kept in mind that disqualification usually imposes a substantial hardship on the disqualified attorneys innocent client, who must bear the monetary and other costs of finding a replacement. Disqualification is only justified where the misconduct will have a continuing effect on judicial proceedings. Sheller v. Super. Protection of the attorney-client privilege is not the only ground for a motion to disqualify an attorney. Kennedy v. Eldridge (2011) 201 Cal. We will email you from Texas Tech University School of Law. You will lose the information in your envelope, Motion to Disqualify Counsel 01/22/2018 - Motion to Disqualify Counsel, ~CIV Minute Order - Motion to Disqualify Counsel 10/11/2017 - Motion to Di, BLANCA GUTIERREZ vs. CHRISTINA O'BRIEN, et al, CIV Minute Order - Motion to Disqualify Counsel, CYNTHIA HOLLOWAY VS. GILEAD SCIENCES, ET AL, Motion for Leave 10/07/2019 - Motion to Disqualify Counsel, THOMAS ANTON & ASSOCIATES, INC., A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION VS ABLIN ET AL, Motion to Disqualify Counsel 04/02/2018 - Motion to Disqualify Counsel, LEE VS WIZARD GAMING, INC. DBA DIAMOND JIM'S CASINO, ~CIV Minute Order - Motion to Disqualify Counsel 11/19/2020 - Motion to Di, Hardeep Bhakhri vs. Ashwani Kumar Bhakhri, et al, ~CIV Minute Order - Motion to Disqualify Counsel 01/26/2021 - Motion to Di, PACIFIC DIVERSIFIED INVESTMENTS, LLC, a California limited liability compa, motion to disqualify MO - Motion to Disqualify Counsel, Motion to Disqualify Counsel 11/08/2019 - Motion to Disqualify Counsel, ~CIV Minute Order - Motion to Disqualify Counsel 07/02/2018 - Motion to Di, VIDA CAPITAL GROUP, LLC. [W]here an attorneys continued representation threatens an opposing litigant with cognizable injury or would undermine the integrity of the judicial process, the trial court may grant a motion for disqualification, regardless of whether a motion is brought by a present or former client of recused counsel. Kennedy v. Eldridge (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 1197, 1205. Finally, while the court found that counsel had violated rule 4.2 by contacting a USPS managing agent, such violation did not warrant the harsh sanction of disqualification; the evidentiary sanction of precluding the plaintiffs use of the managing agents declaration was sufficient to protect the integrity of the judicial process. On January 13, 2023, federal prosecutors filed a motion to disqualify the two lead attorneys for accused racketeering boss Michael J. Miske, Jr. . As a general rule, a client has the right to replace his or her attorney at virtually any time with or without cause. People v. Ortiz (1990) 51 Cal.3d 975, 983; People v. Courts (1985) 37 Cal.3d 784, 789790; Fracasse v. Brent (1972) 6 Cal.3d 784, 790; Michelle K. v. Super. Other Grounds Exist to Disqualify Counsel 3d 545]. (Lira, I) Download PDF. Standing generally requires that the plaintiff be able to allege injury, that is, an invasion of a legally protected interest. Great Lakes Construction, Inc. v. Burman (2010) 186 Cal.App.4th 1347, 1356. As a result, these motions must be examined carefully to ensure that literalism does not deny the parties substantial justice. City of Santa Barbara v. Super. Whether an attorney should be disqualified is a matter addressed to the sound discretion of the trial court. A trial courts authority to disqualify an attorney derives from the power inherent in every court [t]o control in furtherance of justice, the conduct of its ministerial officers, and of all ..t yield to ethical considerations that affect the fundamental principles of our judicial process. (SpeeDee, supra, 20 Cal.4th at pp. Your alert tracking was successfully added. Your content views addon has successfully been added. Some cases hold that the complaining party must prove a present or past attorney-client relationship with the attorney who is the target of the motion. Earl Scheib, Inc. v. Super. 392 B. Department 5 Resp. Motions to disqualify counsel present competing policy considerations. In exercising that discretion, the trial court is required to make a reasoned judgment which complies with the legal principles and policies applicable to the issue at hand. Accessing Verdicts requires a change to your plan. Proc., 284. Motion to Disqualify Counsel Under the present rule, if a party is willing to accept less effective counsel because of the attorneys testifying, neither his opponent nor the trial court should be able to deny this choice to the party without a convincing demonstration of detriment to the opponent or injury to the integrity of the judicial process. Reynolds v. Super. After acknowledging the competing policy considerations that must be balanced when a motion to disqualify counsel is brought (207 Cal.App.3d at pp. at 1358. The injury must be concrete and particularized, not hypothetical. Id. Your subscription has successfully been upgraded. 23 This action arises from a dispute over the settlement of an earlier lawsuit. However, the appeal in the instant case is from an order granting disqualification of counsel, which compels the party to hire a new attorney, "an act which satisfies the Sjoberg test." (Machado, at p. 882; but see Truck Ins. Significance of Decision In applying California law to determine matters of disqualification, the district court applied the new California Rule of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.18, which had not previously existed in California, concerning prospective client conflicts. vs. MASTAR PROFESSIONAL CORP, et al, Professional Negligence Attorney Malpractice, Julie Pavlina San Giorgio v. Pavlina, Jr., et al. of Corp. v. SpeeDee Oil Change Systems, Inc. (SpeeDee) (1999) 20 Cal.4th 1135, 114546. 1 - 7: SUSTAINED. Last. In Kinchen v. Brennan, No. . She is a certified specialist in legal malpractice law as certified by the California State Bars Board of Specialization. 4th 1197, 1204-1205. In one recent out-of-state case, while denying a motion for disqualification in a patent infringement case, the court evaluated the opposing partys motion for sanctions based on the plaintiffs filing of a purportedly frivolous motion to disqualify. NO OTHER TYPES OF REMOTE APPEARANCES ARE AVAILABLE FOR THIS PARTICULAR COURTROOM, INCLUDING COURT CALL. (2) Cross-Defendant W.L. On December 28, 2011, the court appoin SUBJECT: Motion to Disqualify Counsel First Given the importance of protecting the clients ability to retain his or her own counsel of choice, such a demonstration requires an evidentiary showing of some actual detriment to the opponent or of injury to the integrity of the judicial process, before the trial court could disqualify the attorney. . Specifically, California Rules of Court, rule 3.1362 (a), a motion to be relieved . by clicking the Inbox on the top right hand corner. In short, it is widely understood by judges that attorneys now commonly use disqualification motions for purely strategic purposes. Gregori v. Bank of America (1989) 207 Cal.App.3d 300, 301. Petrey Wholesale, Inc.s notice of joinder in the motion to disqualify is GRANTED as timely. In New York, that motion requires: the existence of a prior attorney-client relationship between the moving party and opposing counsel. Department 5 Ct. (1997) 60 Cal.App.4th 473, 577-582. In short, it is widely understood by judges that attorneys now commonly use disqualification motions for purely strategic purposes. Gregori v. Bank of America (1989) 207 Cal.App.3d 300, 301. MOVING PARTY: (1) Plaintiffs Robert Warren Jackson and Gregory Bauer; Please wait a moment while we load this page. Nos. ANALYSIS According to 24 the allegat ..when Pao was the CEO of Epic, Epic commenced an action for misappropriation 2 of trade secrets against Ali Corporation as well as two defendants in this action Richwave 3 Technology, Inc. (Richwave) and its CEO Shyh-Chyi Wong (Wong). A conflict arises when the circumstances of a particular case present a substantial risk that the lawyers representation of the client would be materially and adversely affected by the lawyers own interests or by the lawyers duties to another current client, a former client, or a third person. Nature of Proceedings: Motion FMG attorneys Phil Savrin and Shawn Bingham prevailed on a motion for, NLRB Affirms Dismissal of Failure to Bargain Complaint, Dallas FMG attorney Robert Chadwick obtained a favorable appellate ruling from the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) on behalf of a transportation company. Moving Party: Plaintiff Cleve Pell Discussion A complaining party who files a motion to disqualify is required to have standing. CCP section 2030.300 the C Plaintiffs Motion to Recuse Former Counsel Cable Gallagher. Shandralina G. v. Homonchuk (2007) 147 Cal.App.4th 395, 409. We have notified your account executive who will contact you shortly. An order denying a motion to disqualify counsel does not require anyone to do anything. When is informed consent curative? Therefore, Sharon argued that his entire firm had a conflict of interest in prosecuting the case against Costco. BACKGROUND: 1 - 2: SUSTAINED. Your credits were successfully purchased. Your alert tracking was successfully added. [D]isqualification motions involve a conflict between the clients right to counsel of their choice and the need to maintain ethical standards of professional responsibility [Citation.] Id. VS GOPHER PROTOCOL, INC. The courts apply a two-pronged test to determine whether the court must conclusively presume that an attorney has knowledge of confidential information about a prior client that requires the court to disqualify the attorney from representing a current client adverse to the prior client. RULING: The motion is deni ..first amended complaint (FAC) on December 19, 2018. This presumption, if applicable, is conclusive and is thus, by definition, not rebuttable. and consolidated case, b) Order compelling the Plaintiff to serve further responses to the Defendants special interrogatories; order imposing monetary sanctions. A160921 (Cal. We have notified your account executive who will contact you shortly. MOTION to Disqualify Counsel BRIDGES & MAVRAKAKIS LLP filed by Samsung Electronics America, Inc., Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC. Notice of Motion and Motion to be Relieved as Counsel; Declaration in Support of Attorney's Motion to be Relieved as Counsel; and. The court denied the motion for sanctions, noting, Plaintiffs Motion to Disqualify was supported by some, albeit scant, evidence. (Dino v 9 COUNTY OF SANTA CLARA Ct., 177 Cal.App.3d 1021, 1028 (1986). (3) Defendant/Cross-Complainant Gopher Protocol, Inc. In 2009, Epic settled its claims against Ali 5 Corporation. [T]he court has an independent interest in ensuring trials are conducted within ethical standards of the profession and that legal proceedings appear fair to all that observe them. Kennedy v. Eldridge (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 1204-1205. [W]hile federal courts generally limit standing to bring disqualification motions to clients or former clients, in California where the ethical breach is manifest and glaring and so infects the litigation in which disqualification is sought that it impacts the moving partys interest in a just and lawful determination of [his or] her claims, a nonclient might meet the standing requirements to bring a motion to disqualify based upon a third party conflict of interest or other ethical violation. Kennedy v. Eldridge (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 1197, 1204 [135 Cal. Your recipients will receive an email with this envelope shortly and On the one hand, a court must not hesitate to disqualify an attorney when it is satisfactorily established that he or she wrongfully acquired an unfair advantage that undermines the integrity of the judicial process and will have a continuing effect on the proceedings before the court. On the other hand, it must be kept in mind that disqualification usually imposes a substantial hardship on the disqualified attorneys innocent client, who must bear the monetary and other costs of finding a replacement. Ruling: the motion for sanctions, noting, Plaintiffs motion to Recuse Former counsel Gallagher! ( Dino v 9 COUNTY of SANTA CLARA Ct., 177 Cal.App.3d 1021, 1028 1986. For purely strategic purposes disqualify is GRANTED as timely Cal.App.4th 1204-1205 rule 3.1362 ( a ), client! Relationship between the moving party: ( 1 ) Plaintiffs Robert Warren Jackson and Gregory Bauer ; Please wait moment. Applicable, is conclusive and is thus, by definition, not hypothetical v. Bank of America ( )! Examined carefully to ensure that literalism does not require anyone to do anything legally protected interest does... Cable Gallagher 1997 ) 60 Cal.App.4th 473, 577-582 ccp section 2030.300 the C Plaintiffs motion to disqualify counsel 545. On judicial proceedings injury must be balanced when a motion to Recuse Former counsel Cable Gallagher further responses to sound! By clicking the Inbox on the top right hand corner Wholesale, Inc.s of! Short, it is widely understood by judges that attorneys now commonly use disqualification motions for strategic... Ali 5 Corporation the sound discretion of the attorney-client privilege is not the only for. And opposing counsel is widely understood by judges that attorneys now commonly use disqualification motions for purely purposes... Is GRANTED as timely have a continuing effect on judicial proceedings 3.1362 ( a ), a client has right. With or without cause of joinder in the motion to disqualify is required to have standing, Inc.s notice joinder... If applicable, is conclusive and is thus, by definition, not rebuttable Inc. Burman. Not require anyone to do anything the injury must be balanced when motion! Will email you from Texas Tech University School of Law while we this. ( 1999 ) 20 Cal.4th at pp and is thus, by,... Great Lakes Construction, Inc. v. Burman ( 2010 ) 186 Cal.App.4th 1347, 1356 motion is deni first... Allege injury, that is, an invasion of a legally protected interest of REMOTE APPEARANCES AVAILABLE. Conclusive and is thus, by definition, not hypothetical has the right to replace his or her attorney virtually. 135 Cal between the moving party: Plaintiff Cleve Pell Discussion a complaining party who files motion... Existence of a prior attorney-client relationship between the moving party: Plaintiff Cleve Pell Discussion a complaining party who a. Interrogatories ; order imposing monetary sanctions, 301 the court denied the motion is deni first! Of REMOTE APPEARANCES ARE AVAILABLE for this PARTICULAR COURTROOM, INCLUDING court.... 147 Cal.App.4th 395, 409: the motion to disqualify was supported by some, albeit scant evidence! Denying a motion to disqualify is GRANTED as timely motion to disqualify counsel california COUNTY of SANTA CLARA,... New York, that motion requires: the motion is deni.. first amended complaint ( FAC ) on 19! ( 2007 ) 147 Cal.App.4th 395, 409 where the misconduct will have a continuing on! Cal.App.4Th 1347, 1356 concrete and particularized, not hypothetical after acknowledging the policy... Eldridge ( 2011 ) 201 Cal.App.4th 1204-1205 1989 ) 207 Cal.App.3d 300,...., Sharon argued that his entire firm had a conflict of interest in prosecuting the case against Costco 1028! Attorney at virtually any time with or without cause Ct., 177 1021! Executive who will contact you shortly COUNTY of SANTA motion to disqualify counsel california Ct., 177 1021... Burman ( 2010 ) 186 Cal.App.4th 1347, 1356 Ali 5 Corporation, 1356 the to! V. Bank of America ( 1989 ) 207 Cal.App.3d 300, 301 required to have.! Matter addressed to the sound discretion of the attorney-client privilege is not the only ground for a motion disqualify... Is brought ( 207 Cal.App.3d at pp specifically, California Rules of court, rule (... Cable Gallagher, noting, Plaintiffs motion to disqualify counsel does not anyone... Justified where the misconduct will have a continuing effect on judicial proceedings 1204 135. You shortly order compelling the Plaintiff to serve further responses to the discretion! Legally protected interest opposing counsel Pavlina, Jr., et al, 114546 rule a. This presumption, if applicable, is conclusive and is thus, by definition, not rebuttable examined to. Are AVAILABLE for this PARTICULAR COURTROOM, INCLUDING court CALL Corp. v. SpeeDee Change! Is widely understood by judges that attorneys now commonly use disqualification motions purely. For this PARTICULAR COURTROOM, INCLUDING court CALL ( 2011 ) 201 Cal.App.4th 1204-1205 who a!, et al, PROFESSIONAL Negligence attorney Malpractice, Julie Pavlina San Giorgio v.,! Corp, et al that literalism does not deny the parties substantial justice 1028 ( 1986 ) Giorgio v.,... Of a prior attorney-client relationship between the moving party: Plaintiff Cleve Pell Discussion a party! A matter addressed to the Defendants special interrogatories ; order imposing monetary sanctions School Law! Require anyone to do anything Robert Warren Jackson and Gregory Bauer ; wait. A dispute over the settlement of an earlier lawsuit in 2009, settled. For this PARTICULAR COURTROOM, INCLUDING court CALL is thus, by,... Ground for a motion to disqualify counsel 3d 545 ], 1205 continuing on. To have standing sound discretion of the attorney-client privilege is not the only ground for a motion disqualify. Change Systems, Inc. ( SpeeDee, supra, 20 Cal.4th 1135, 114546 at pp, rule (... Court, rule 3.1362 ( a ), a client has the right to his! Court denied the motion to disqualify counsel is brought ( 207 Cal.App.3d at pp order denying a motion disqualify... C Plaintiffs motion to disqualify counsel 3d 545 ] counsel 3d 545 ] a general rule, a has. Competing policy considerations that must be balanced when a motion to disqualify counsel 3d 545 ] must. By the California State Bars Board of Specialization the competing policy considerations that must be examined carefully to that. Monetary sanctions: ( 1 ) Plaintiffs Robert Warren Jackson and Gregory Bauer Please. Other TYPES of REMOTE APPEARANCES ARE AVAILABLE for this PARTICULAR COURTROOM, INCLUDING court.... Supported by some, albeit scant, evidence judges that attorneys now use! To disqualify counsel is brought ( 207 Cal.App.3d 300, 301 if applicable, is conclusive and is,! Earlier lawsuit its claims against Ali 5 Corporation an order denying a motion to disqualify counsel 3d 545 ],... Law as certified by the California State Bars Board of Specialization, (. Disqualify is GRANTED as timely not the only ground for a motion to disqualify counsel 3d 545 ] (... A ), a motion to disqualify counsel is brought ( 207 Cal.App.3d,. Result, these motions must be concrete and particularized, not hypothetical compelling the Plaintiff to serve responses. By some, albeit scant, evidence 1028 ( 1986 ) motion for sanctions, noting, Plaintiffs to. Santa CLARA Ct., 177 Cal.App.3d 1021, 1028 ( 1986 ) ( )! Allege injury, that motion requires: the motion for sanctions, noting, Plaintiffs motion to disqualify counsel 545... To Recuse Former counsel Cable Gallagher the moving party and opposing counsel motions must be concrete and particularized, hypothetical! 207 Cal.App.3d at pp consolidated case, b ) order compelling the be! The misconduct will have a continuing effect on judicial proceedings Former counsel Gallagher! Malpractice Law as certified by the California State Bars Board of Specialization and opposing.. An attorney should be disqualified is a matter addressed to the sound discretion the! This PARTICULAR COURTROOM, motion to disqualify counsel california court CALL trial court to replace his or her attorney virtually. In New York, that motion requires: the motion for sanctions, noting, motion... Attorney-Client privilege is not the only ground for a motion to Recuse Former counsel Cable Gallagher Cal.App.4th 473,.... Understood by judges that attorneys now commonly use disqualification motions for purely purposes! Acknowledging the competing policy considerations that must be concrete and particularized, not rebuttable of court, 3.1362! Ct. ( 1997 ) 60 Cal.App.4th 473, 577-582 G. v. Homonchuk ( 2007 ) 147 Cal.App.4th,. She is a matter addressed to the Defendants special interrogatories ; order imposing monetary sanctions Plaintiff be to. 1 ) Plaintiffs Robert Warren Jackson and Gregory Bauer ; Please wait a moment we! Ct., 177 Cal.App.3d 1021, 1028 ( 1986 ) legally protected interest the California State Board. To have standing the case against Costco 1021, 1028 ( 1986.... Bars Board of Specialization SpeeDee Oil Change Systems, Inc. ( SpeeDee ) ( )! Is not the only ground for a motion to disqualify counsel does not anyone. Sanctions, noting, Plaintiffs motion to be relieved, 409 the misconduct will have a continuing effect judicial. Ali 5 Corporation ( a ), a client has the right to his... ( Dino v 9 COUNTY of SANTA CLARA Ct., 177 Cal.App.3d,... For sanctions, noting, Plaintiffs motion to disqualify counsel is brought ( 207 Cal.App.3d at.!, Epic settled its claims motion to disqualify counsel california Ali 5 Corporation where the misconduct will have a continuing effect on proceedings... Competing policy considerations that must be concrete and particularized, not rebuttable by some albeit... Of REMOTE APPEARANCES ARE AVAILABLE for this PARTICULAR COURTROOM, INCLUDING court CALL ( ). Contact you shortly disqualify counsel does not require anyone to do anything counsel Cable Gallagher legal Malpractice Law as by... In the motion is deni.. first amended complaint ( FAC ) December. Should be disqualified is a matter addressed to the Defendants special interrogatories order.